Mount Washington Valley Astronomy

Astronomy and Science News

More on NASA’s “Life on Mars” Controversy

  • August
  • 8

by Josh Hill

Mars_cover_2 The Mars Phoenix mission has finally managed to bring NASA back in to the spotlight. The hype is beginning to rival the days man would set foot on the moon, but this time, we’re hoping that we find life on another planet.

But over the weekend, as NASA spokesman Duane Brown describes it, a mass of “speculation and rumor” cropped up regarding a discovery that the Phoenix Lander had made. The Phoenix Lander had discovered perchlorates in the soil of Mars, and this sparked rumors that there was the possibility of life on Mars, as well as the opposite, that there was a hindrance to life on Mars.

And so NASA dragged their scientists in to a press-conference with the intention of shedding a little light on what was happening behind the scenes. But due to the fact that there are literally no confirmed results, let alone peer-reviewed, the scientists were doing so begrudgingly. Mike Meyer, the head of NASA’s Mars efforts, said, “We’re here today to announce a nonannouncement—more experiments and time are needed to resolve the results of the science experiments.”

The leader of the project, Peter Smith, was a little more relaxed about the move. He described the decision to hold this press conference as a “break with scientific tradition” but that it was akin to “opening a window to allow the public to see the scientific process in action.”

Perchlorates are the salts that are derived from perchloric acid, and are found naturally on Earth, in such places as Chile’s hyper-arid Atacama Desert. The compound is stable, according to NASA’s press release, and does not destroy organic material under standard circumstances. In fact, some microorganisms on Earth are fueled by processes that involve perchlorates. But most importantly to the discovery on Mars, is that perchlorates are oxidants, in other words, they can release oxygen.

“Finding perchlorates is neither good nor bad for life, but it does make us reassess how we think about life on Mars,” said Michael Hecht of NASA’s Jet Propulsion Laboratory, Pasadena, Calif., lead scientist for the Microscopy, Electrochemistry and Conductivity Analyzer (MECA), the instrument that includes the wet chemistry laboratory. If confirmed, the result is exciting, Hecht said, “because different types of perchlorate salts have interesting properties that may bear on the way things work on Mars if — and that’s a big ‘if ‘ — the results from our two teaspoons of soil are representative of all of Mars, or at least a significant portion of the planet.”

Samples of dirt had been taken from two locations, the Dodo-Goldilocks trench on Sol 25 (June 25) and Snow White trench on Sol 41 (July 6). When the Thermal and Evolved-Gas Analyzer (TEGA) heated a sample of the soil from the Dodo-Goldilocks trench, it detected a release of oxygen. According to TEGA lead scientist William Boynton of the University of Arizona, perchlorates are one of several possible sources for this release of oxygen.

However Boynton and his team are unsure what they are dealing with. Though some perchlorates will not release chlorine when heated, some will, and the lack of chlorine being emitted by any of the samples run through TEGA are muddying the waters.

Which brings everything back to the fact that no one is really quite certain just what any of this means. NASA may very well have found perchlorates on Mars, and they may not have. What has to happen now, and what NASA scientists probably wanted to do anyway before they made any of this public, is nail down just what it is they have found in the Mars soil.

Source:

http://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/phoenix/news/phoenix-20080805.html

Sphere: Related Content

1 commentExtraterrestrial Life, Solar System

The White House is Briefed: “Potential For Life” on Mars

  • August
  • 3
The surface zones where samples have been excavated by Phoenix (NASA)

The surface zones where samples have been excavated by Phoenix (NASA)

It would appear that the US President has been briefed by Phoenix scientists about the discovery of something more “provocative” than the discovery of water existing on the Martian surface. This news comes just as the Thermal and Evolved Gas Analyzer (TEGA) confirmed experimental evidence for the existence of water in the Mars regolith on Thursday. Whilst NASA scientists are not claiming that life once existed on the Red Planet’s surface, new data appears to indicate the “potential for life” more conclusively than the TEGA water results. Apparently these new results are being kept under wraps until further, more detailed analysis can be carried out, but we are assured that this announcement will be huge

So why is there all this secrecy? According to scientists in communication with Aviation Week & Space Technology, the next big discovery will need to be mulled over for a while before it is announced to the world. In fact, the Jet Propulsion Laboratory science team for the MECA wet-chemistry instrument that made these undisclosed findings were kept out of the July 31st news conference (confirming water) so additional analysis could be carried out, avoiding any questions that may have revealed their preliminary results. They have also made the decision to discuss the results with the Bush Administration’s Presidential Science Advisor’s office before a press conference between mid-August and early September.

Although good news, Thursday’s announcement of the discovery of water on Mars comes as no surprise to mission scientists and some are amused by the media’s reaction to the TEGA results. “They have discovered water on Mars for the third or fourth time,” one senior Mars scientist joked. These new MECA results are, according to the Phoenix team, a little more complex than the water “discovery.” Scientists are keen to point out however, that this secretive news will in no way indicate the existence of life (past or present) on Mars; Phoenix simply is not equipped make this discovery. What it can do is test the Mars soil for compounds suitable to support life. The MECA instrument does have microscopes capable of resolving bacterial-scale life forms however, but this is not the focus of the forthcoming announcement, sources say.

This new MECA discovery, combined with TEGA data will probably expose something more compelling, completing another piece of the puzzle in the search for the correct conditions for life as we know it to survive on Mars. Critical to this search is to understand how the recently confirmed water and Mars regolith behave together under the Phoenix lander in the cold Martian arctic.

The MECA instrument had already made the landmark discovery that Mars “soil” was much like the soil more familiar on Earth. This finding prompted scientists to indicate that the minerals and pH levels in the regolith could support some terrestrial plants, indicating this would be useful for future Mars settlers.

What with the discovery of water, and the discovery that Mars soil is very much like the stuff we find on Earth, it is hard to guess as to what the MECA’s second soil test has discovered. What ever it is, it sounds pretty significant, especially as NASA and the University of Arizona are taking extraordinary steps to avoid any more details being leaked to the outside world. I just hope were not getting excited over something benign…

original source:http://www.universetoday.com/

http://www.aviationweek.com/

Sphere: Related Content

No commentsExtraterrestrial Life, Solar System


© 2008 Mount Washington Valley Astronomy - Hosted by; Muracco Enterprises